The Antietam Valley Shopping Center was built in 1961 along St. Lawrence Avenue and Perkiomen Avenue on the edge of St. Lawrence and Mt. Penn. At the time of the picture above in 1969 various smaller stores included a state store, beer distributor, pastry shop, Merchants, insurance and more. Larger anchors included Woolworth’s and Pantry Pride. The strip mall was renovated in 1990.
The shopping mall has faced tenant issues and is a shell of its former self with at one point only half of the retail spaces being occupied. It was sold in 2016 for $2.45 million. Many blame the newer shopping centers built further down route 422 in Exeter for the lack of foot traffic and interest in the Antietam Valley Shopping Center.
In 2019, a fairly popular indoor flea market that called one of the retail spaces home was shuttered due to a real estate dispute. The owner wanted the space vacant so renovations could take place and to then raise the rent because the building would be newly renovated.
Currently the Antietam Valley Shopping Center is home to a gym, Dollar General, Rite aid, physical therapy center, laundromat, beer distributor and daycare center. It is unclear whether renovations have taken place but the property is actively listed online looking for new tenants to fill the empty spaces.